Best Pacifiers for Newborns: A Mom’s Guide to Sweet, Soothing Success

Let’s face it, pacifiers are basically tiny miracles disguised as baby accessories. They calm meltdowns, save nap time, and sometimes, just sometimes, give you a minute to drink a cup of coffee while it’s still hot. But choosing the right pacifier for your newborn? That’s a whole other level of parenting! From safety and comfort to style and functionality, there’s a lot to consider. Don’t worry, I’ve done the homework for you! Let’s dive into the best pacifiers that’ll keep your little one (and you) happy.

Benefits of Using Pacifiers for Newborns

Pacifiers aren’t just lifesavers for parents, they come with real benefits for your baby too!

• Soothe and Comfort: A pacifier can help your newborn self-soothe during stressful or overstimulating moments.
  
  

• Reduced Risk of SIDS: Research shows that offering a pacifier during sleep can lower the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).
  
  

• Support Better Sleep: Babies often fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer when they have a pacifier to soothe them.
  
  

• Pain Relief: Sucking on a pacifier can distract and comfort your baby during vaccinations or teething discomfort.

Pro tip: Wait until breastfeeding is well-established (around 3-4 weeks) before introducing a pacifier to avoid nipple confusion.

Best Overall Pacifier: MAM Pacifiers

If you’re looking for a pacifier that checks all the boxes, MAM Pacifiers are a clear winner. Designed with safety and comfort in mind, these pacifiers have a one-piece construction to reduce choking hazards. Made from BPA- and BPS-free silicone, they’re gentle on your baby’s delicate skin.

What’s even better? They come with a sterilizer box for easy microwave cleaning (because who has time for complicated cleaning routines?). Oh, and did I mention they’ve won safety awards? Yup, MAM knows what they’re doing.

Price: Starting at $6.99
Where to Buy: MAM Baby Official Website

Most Stylish Pacifier: Mushie FRIGG Pacifiers

For moms who love a bit of flair, the Mushie FRIGG pacifiers are like the Instagram influencers of the pacifier world. They’re made from 100% natural rubber and come in gorgeous, minimalist colors like dusty rose and sage green.

The outward curve design keeps your baby’s face dry (bye-bye, drool rash), and they’re free from BPA, PVC, and other nasty chemicals. While they require manual cleaning (no dishwasher or sterilizer, unfortunately), the style points they earn might just be worth it.

Price: Starting at $8.99
Where to Buy: Mushie Official Website

Most Versatile Pacifier: Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier

If your baby is a bit picky about pacifiers, Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT pacifiers are the solution. These innovative pacifiers double as teethers, making them a 2-in-1 gem for soothing gums during teething.

They come in a variety of nipple shapes, round, flat, or orthodontic, so you can find the one your baby loves most. Made from medical-grade silicone, they’re soft, safe, and dishwasher-friendly (hooray for easy cleanup!).

Price: $12.99
Where to Buy: Ryan & Rose Official Website

Best Natural Pacifier: Natursutten Pacifiers

For moms going au naturel, Natursutten pacifiers are the ultimate choice. Crafted from 100% natural rubber, these pacifiers are free from harmful chemicals, dyes, and allergens.

The one-piece design prevents dirt and bacteria from hiding in crevices, and the soft, flexible material mimics the feel of a mother’s nipple, perfect for breastfed babies. Plus, they’re available in two nipple shapes (round and orthodontic) and three sizes to grow with your baby.

Price: Starting at $10.99
Where to Buy: Natursutten Official Website

Best Nighttime Pacifier: BIBS Glow-in-the-Dark Pacifiers

Stumbling around in the dark looking for a lost pacifier? Not with BIBS Glow-in-the-Dark pacifiers! These genius soothers feature a glow handle, so you can find them even in pitch black without waking the baby.

Made from natural rubber and available in several nipple shapes, BIBS pacifiers are as functional as they are adorable. They’re also lightweight and gentle on gums, making them a favorite for babies and parents alike.

Price: $15.99 (2-pack)
Where to Buy: BIBS Official Website

Features to Look for in a Newborn Pacifier

When choosing a pacifier, keep these important features in mind:

• One-Piece Design: Reduces choking hazards by eliminating small parts.
  
  

• Safety Shield: Should be at least 1.5 inches wide to prevent swallowing
  .

• Durable Materials: Opt for food-grade silicone or natural rubber for safety.
  
  

• Ease of Cleaning: Dishwasher- or sterilizer-safe options save you time.
  
  

• Nipple Shape: Experiment with different shapes (round, orthodontic, flat) to find your baby’s favorite.

Safety Tips for Using Pacifiers

Your baby’s safety is the top priority, so here are a few pacifier safety tips:

• Always inspect pacifiers for cracks or wear before use.

• Replace pacifiers every 1-2 months to maintain hygiene and safety.

• Avoid attaching pacifiers to your baby’s neck or crib with strings.

• Sterilize pacifiers regularly, especially before the first use.

Tips for Introducing a Pacifier to Your Baby

Wondering how to get your baby to accept a pacifier? Here’s what worked for me:

Timing is Everything: Offer the pacifier after feedings when your baby is calm and content.

Dip it in Milk: For breastfed babies, dipping the pacifier in breastmilk can make it more appealing.

Try Different Shapes: Babies can be picky, experiment with different nipple shapes until you find the one they like.

Be Patient: If your baby spits it out, don’t force it. Try again later.

FAQs About Pacifiers For Newborns 

Can Pacifiers Affect Breastfeeding?

Yes, introducing a pacifier too early (before breastfeeding is well-established) can lead to nipple confusion. Wait until 3-4 weeks if you’re breastfeeding.

How Do I Wean My Baby Off a Pacifier?

Start by limiting pacifier use to naps and bedtime. Gradually phase it out by offering other comfort items like a blanket or stuffed toy.

Are There Age Limits for Pacifier Use?

Pediatricians recommend stopping pacifier use by age 3 to avoid dental issues.

How Should I Clean Pacifiers?

Sterilize new pacifiers before first use and clean them regularly with warm, soapy water or in the dishwasher (if safe).

Can I Use a Pacifier for a Colicky Baby?

Yes, pacifiers can help soothe colicky babies by satisfying their natural sucking reflex and providing comfort.

Finding the best pacifier for your newborn can feel overwhelming, but the right choice can make a world of difference for both you and your baby. Whether you go for the stylish Mushie FRIGG, the versatile Ryan & Rose, or the eco-friendly Natursutten, you can rest easy knowing your little one is soothed and safe. Now, go enjoy that coffee while it’s still warm, you’ve got this!