This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Free Shipping for all US orders over $50

Baby's First Christmas Gift Guide

Baby's First Christmas Gift Guide

Baby's First Christmas Gift Guide

Have yourself a merry (and easy-to-shop-for) Christmas with our list of the best gift ideas for a new baby. We've handpicked these goodies with love and care, ensuring they're just as special as the tiny tot who'll be receiving them. They can’t thank you, but they would if they could.

Personalized Gifts

Toys and presents with your child's name on them are always a hit, especially for a baby's first Christmas and holiday season. These thoughtful and unique holiday gifts add an extra touch of love and thoughtfulness to any gift. Some great personalized gift ideas include:

Holiday Heirloom Baby Blanket

Keep baby warm (and festive) with this soft fleece, quilted blanket! Make it personalized with an added name or monogram! The perfect first Christmas gift and great for holiday photos!

First Christmas Ornament

Commemorate baby’s first Christmas with personalized frame ornaments for the family's Christmas tree! A gift that will be cherished for holidays to come! 

Pinhole Press Board Book

Create a custom baby board book filled with photos of mom, dad, and the rest of the family. A perfect present that doubles as a baby keepsake! 

Wooden Name Puzzle

Customize with baby’s name! The best presents are those that grow with your baby! You can use it as cute nursery decor now and when they’re older, watch as your baby’s little hands manipulate the pieces and work on fine motor skills. And as baby grows into toddlerhood, you can use it to recognize their name, colors and shapes.

Night Before Christmas Personalized Book

Baby books make a great gift! Personalize this seasonal classic with a few special details about your little one. From your child’s name to a custom dedication, this favorite story is updated with unique elements that transform it into a one-of-a-kind Christmas book. Santa approved!

Baby Handprint Ornament

A baby keepsake that captures a special milestone is the perfect gift that gets more special in years to come! If you get an extra one for grandparents, it may earn you some brownie points!

Heirloom Quilted Tree Advent Calendar

Enjoy this perfect gift for years to come! Add an extra special touch with a monogram or name!

Fun and Playful Gifts

Want to find some fun and playful baby Christmas gifts? Take a look at these adorable options that are guaranteed to bring a smile to any child's face.

Poppyseed Play's Wood + Silicone Teether

A teething toy is one of the best gifts you can get for a baby and will easily become a family favorite! The soft, flexible silicone helps to massage and soothe while the natural wood provides a firm surface for chewing. Plus, the various textures of these super cute teethers help to stimulate your baby's senses. BPA-free, Lead-free, PVC-free, Phthalates-free. Not teething yet? Oh, they will be soon enough!

Poppyseed Play's Wooden Baby Gym

A play gym for babies is one toy that will be used often throughout his/her first year of life. Watch as your child explores the delightful hanging toys, honing their hand-eye coordination, practicing their kicking and gross motor skills, and strengthening their little bodies during tummy time. The Poppyseed Play baby gym is not only functional, but is also adorable and look beautiful in any home.

Poppyseed Play's Infant Play Mat

Introduce babies to floor time early (and comfortably) with a machine-washable, triple-padded play mat. The baby play mat is soft and gentle on your child's skin (you can never start a good skincare routine too early, right?), making it perfect for playtime or nap time.

Little Mae & Co Boppy/Pillow Cover

Uniquely designed feeding support pillows designed to perfectly fit for nursing or for baby tummy time. Modern patterns and prints to match your nursery decor. Machine washable and can be tumbled dry. BONUS - A teething toy attachment option for teething relief + play.

Indestructibles Book

One thing we know? Everything goes in your baby’s mouth. Which is why you can’t go wrong with books that are chew-proof, rip-proof and non-toxic. Parents don’t just want this - they need this.

Black + White Board Books

Babies can’t see bright colors to start! High-contrast black and white books are great for their developing vision! 

Cuddle + Kind Stuffed Animal

Create a sense of calm and safety at a very young age with a special stuffed animal! Cuddle + Kind produces adorable, ethically-made dolls that provide nutritious meals to children in need. Grab the reindeer to commemorate your baby's first Christmas! 

Kiwi Co Panda Crate Subscription 

A gift box with age-appropriate, high-quality products and toys that nurture your little one's growing brain through fun & engaging play. 0-36 months old. The Christmas gift that keeps on giving! 

Nursery Gifts

Welcome to the world of new parents! It's an exciting time filled with love and joy, but also sleepless nights and endless diaper changes. You may be wondering what presents would make the perfect addition to the nursery for this little bundle of joy. Let's take a look at some great nursery gift ideas!

Pottery Barn Lovey

For fussy bedtimes and on-the-go adventures, this plush lovey is a must-have and keeps your little one company while providing that snug and secure feeling. An all-in-one security blanket and sleep buddy that’s easier to keep track of. And it’s machine washable!

Pottery Barn Chair

Add this comfy, kid-sized chair to any room and create a special spot for reading, relaxing or snuggling. Also great for monthly milestone photos! Add your baby’s name for a personal touch!

Frida Baby Basics Kit

Practical newborn baby kit which tackles baby snot, gas relief, nail clipping and rough skin with one convenient gift box ready set!

Clothing Gifts

Are you searching for a delightful wearable to commemorate the holidy season? Look no further! We have curated a collection of newborn Christmas gifts, ranging from adorable onesies to charming bibs.

Christmas Pajamas

A baby’s very first Christmas calls for pajamas that match the holiday season! Give on Christmas Eve so your baby can wake up on Christmas morning looking as festive (and cute as ever) to unwrap the rest of the presents you found in our super helpful gift guide. 

Quinn St. Bamboo Baby Clothes

Cozy enough for sleep, cute enough for all day play. Celebrate little one’s arrival with a newborn bundle, or ribbed knotted sleepers (which make middle-of-the-night diaper changes a breeze). 

Copper Pearl Bibs + Burp Cloths

From neutral to bright colors, Copper Pearl offers a variety of drool-worthy accessories to help with drool (duh), spit up and a multitude of other bodily functions.

Avent Soothie

Comes with the 0-3 month Soothie pacifier! Easily detach the plush toy for cleaning purposes. The stuffed animal makes the pacifier easy for parents and babies to find! Lots of animals to choose from! These make for great newborn gifts! Bonus: They have a reindeer that’s holiday themed! 

Solly Baby Wrap

Do you have older kids to tend to, but your baby doesn’t want to be put down? Enter the Solly baby wrap. Experience reduced infant crying, enhanced connection, and convenient hands-free wearing with the luxuriously soft and breathable Solly Wrap.



Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $50 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase