10 Best Crib Mattress Options for Your Little One

Choosing the right crib mattress is critical for your baby’s safety and comfort, and frankly, for your sleep and sanity too.

In this guide, we’ll explore what makes a crib mattress suitable for your little one, from firmness and non-toxic materials to the perfect snug fit in the crib. Expect straightforward advice on the top mattresses on the market, each carefully evaluated to meet your baby’s developmental needs!

What to Look for in a Crib Mattress

When it comes to crib mattresses, your mission is to find more than a comfortable resting place, but also making safety and quality a top priority.

Here are some essential features you should add to your crib mattress buying checklist:

Made of non-toxic, hypoallergenic material. Your list of priorities should begin with providing your baby with a safe and non-toxic environment while they sleep peacefully. Ideally, you should stay away from a mattress core that has foam, latex, or adhesives. Additionally, consider hypoallergenic materials to minimize allergens and protect your baby’s sensitive skin.
Fits perfectly with the crib frame. It’s crucial that the mattress is a perfect fit for the frame. This means it's tight enough to not have a significant gap where tiny limbs could potentially become trapped.
Has adequate firmness. A mattress that's too soft won't be supportive enough for your baby's developing skills, such as tummy time and sitting up. Of course, a mattress that's too firm simply isn't comfortable, so you need to strike the perfect balance.
Washable. If possible, opt for a washable crib mattress. Washable mattresses have enhanced breathability, hygiene, and convenience. They can also help to minimize the risk of suffocation, regulate the baby’s body temperature, and reduce dust mites and allergens.
Certifications. Lastly, your choice of mattress should have certifications like the esteemed Greenguard Gold Certification which guarantees minimal chemical emissions, or the OEKO-Tex which certifies that a mattress is 100% safe for human health.

Aside from this, consider buying a waterproof mattress protector alongside your crib mattress. More than just protection from little accidents, it stands as an unsung savior through nighttime mishaps allowing swift cleanups and ensuring each morning begins fresh.

A Quick Peek at the Best Crib Mattresses

Before we dive into the details, here’s a quick glance at our tops picks for the best crib mattresses available, each distinguished by its own notable feature.

Best for Breathability: Newton Crib Mattress
Best for Variety: Sealy Baby Crib Mattresses
Best Eco-Friendly Option: Naturepedic Organic Breathable Crib Mattress
Best Unique Feature: Saatva Crib Mattress
Best Luxury Pick: Avocado Organic Crib Mattress
Best Lightweight Design: Lullaby Earth Crib Mattress
Best Budget-Friendly Choice: Graco Premium Foam Mattress
Best for Firm Support: Dream On Me Twinkle Mattress
Best Hypoallergenic Option: Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress
Best Dual-Sided Design: Babyletto Pure Core Mattress

We’re excited to reveal the unique qualities each of these mattresses have to offer for the nursery, ranging from their eco-friendly features to their perfect size. Some of the top picks include a dual-sided mattress for added versatility.

1. Best for Breathability - The Newton Crib Mattress - $299.99

Pros:

97% more air while breathing through the breathable mattress
Reduces the suffocation risk and overheating
Waterproof toddler side available
Machine washable cover with removable cover

Cons:

Higher price point compared to other infant to toddler mattress competitors

Highlights:

The Newton Crib Mattress distinguishes itself as a notable selection within the realm of crib mattresses, and for several good reasons.

For one, it allows a staggering 97% more air to flow compared to traditional mattresses, reducing the risk of suffocation and sweaty backs. This breathable mattress also aids in temperature regulation, ensuring your baby stays cool and comfortable. That's because it circulates air freely, even when your little one snuggles face-down into their mattress.

It's not a waterproof mattress, but the washable cover makes cleaning up after accidents a breeze, keeping the sleep environment fresh and hygienic. It also makes it easy to wash after spit up, ensuring a comfortable and safe sleeping environment for the baby.

While the Newton Crib Mattress does appear to be a more expensive option than other baby crib mattresses, it offers unparalleled comfort and safety that justifies the cost. Providing peace of mind with its superior breathability features, this mattress represents a significant investment for parents who value ensuring their baby’s well-being above everything else.

Rating:

Breathability: 5/5
Hygiene: 4.5/5
Value for Money: 4/5

2. Best for Variety - The Sealy Baby Crib Mattresses - Starts at $64.99

Pros:

Selection of types to cater to different needs
Firmer side for newborns and softer side for toddlers
Foam and innerspring options
2-stage design for infants and toddlers

Cons:

Some models may be heavier and harder to maneuver

Highlights:

Sealy Baby Crib Mattresses are some of the best mattress options if you want variety. This crib mattress brand presents an assortment reminiscent of a lavish buffet. The lineup includes both foam and innerspring varieties.

For those who prefer it, Sealy also offers a foam mattress option. The dual-stage design adapts like a cocoon for your evolving little one – delivering the solid support needed by infants, which then transitions to the gentler side suitable for an active toddler.

While embracing variety adds zest to life, it’s important to point out that some Sealy mattresses come with extra weight that could turn changing sheets into quite the exercise routine. Despite this minor inconvenience, their reputation as America’s healthiest choice and bestseller status is undeniable. Parents consistently rely on its well-established name and wide-ranging collection time after time.

Rating:

Variety: 5/5
Adaptability: 4.5/5
Ease of Use: 3.5/5

Best Eco-Friendly Option - Naturepedic Organic Breathable( 2-Stage) Crib Mattress - $359.00

Pros:

Removable washable layer for breathability
GOTS certified organic cotton
Dual-sided design for infants and toddlers
GREENGUARD Gold Certified

Cons:

Some reported issues with surface unevenness over time

Highlights:

Naturepedic’s Organic Breathable 2-Stage Baby Crib Mattress epitomizes eco-conscious caregiving, offering GOTS certified organic cotton wrapping and a waterproof surface derived from non-GMO sugarcane. The mattress is constructed using organic and sustainable materials, ensuring a healthier sleep environment for your baby.

This crib mattress has a dual-sided design, which means it can adjust to the changing needs of your growing child from infancy to toddlerhood. The only downside based on verified buyer reviews is that the mattress' surface can become irregular over time, which could affect the baby's comfort.

Nevertheless, Naturepedic’s dedication to exceptional standards is evident in their offering of both a 100-night trial and a lifelong warranty. They've definitely established this crib mattress as a symbol of confidence for those searching for an environmentally responsible choice for their infant’s slumber sanctuary.

Rating:

Eco-Friendliness: 5/5
Durability: 3.5/5
Health & Safety: 5/5

Best Unique Feature - Saatva Crib Mattress - $355.00

Pros:

Lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials
GOTS-certified organic cotton
Water-resistant cover
Unique coil design keeps child centered on the crib

Cons:

Premium price may not fit all budgets

Highlights:

If you want a hint of opulence in your baby's sleeping space, you can't go wrong with the Saatva Crib Mattress.

This breathable mattress is crafted with the finest GOTS-certified organic soft cotton. It has a firm support base woven with, as the name implies, breathable eucalyptus fiber.

One of its main features is that it's a coil mattress. It has a mattress core consisting of 200 recycled steel coils designed with a center zone technology. This innovative design keeps your baby centered and away from the edges of the crib.

That said, the Saatva Crib Mattress is on the more expensive side of things. It makes up for it with its lifetime guarantee, though. Plus, the brand has earned an outstanding A+ score from the Better Business Bureau.

Ultimately, this mattress not only indulges your baby but is also designed to endure over time, presenting it as a sumptuous option for anyone seeking top-tier comfort for their baby right from the start.

Rating:

Luxury & Comfort: 5/5
Safety: 4.5/5
Value for Money: 4/5

Best Luxury Pick - Avocado Organic Crib Mattress - $1379

Pros:

Handcrafted with eco-friendly materials
Peace of mind with non-toxic construction
MADE SAFE and GREENGUARD Gold certifications.

Cons:

Limited availability due to handcrafting

Highlights:

The Avocado Organic Crib Mattress is a haven of rest for your baby, similar to a healthy green smoothie brimming with purity and essential nutrients.

Crafted from sustainable and natural materials like organic cotton, wool, and coconut husk, it provides an eco-conscious sleep environment that’s as kind to your little one as it is to the Earth. Boasting certifications including MADE SAFE and GREENGUARD Gold, this mattress ensures safety and cleanliness in the sanctuary of your baby’s crib. Additionally, the use of natural materials in its construction further enhances its eco-friendly appeal.

Due to its artisanal construction and high demand for premium quality products made from sustainable materials, there may be some wait time before you can secure this mattress. But if enduring value on ecological conservation paired with skilled craftsmanship ranks high on your priority list, the Avocado Organic Crib Mattress represents an exemplary choice – providing peace of mind alongside serene slumber within the safe confines of organic luxury for babies.

Rating:

Organic Materials: 5/5
Health & Safety: 5/5
Availability: 3.5/5

Best Lightweight Design - Lullaby Earth Crib Mattress - $199.00

Pros:

Easy to change sheets due to lightweight build
Breathable and washable cover
Environmentally friendly recycled materials

Cons:

Some concerns about firmness and potential sagging

Highlights:

The Lullaby Earth Crib Mattress stands out as a top choice for parents thanks to its array of appealing features. It has a lightweight design for easy crib sheets changes and a breathable and washable cover for a clean sleep environment. Also, it's created from recycled materials, which makes it quite an eco-friendly option.

For transparency's sake, we'd like to note that there has been some concerns among parents in the verified buyer reviews regarding the mattress’s firmness over time. According to the reviews, this crib mattress has a tendency to come way too rigid, only to start sagging in the future.

Despite these concerns, those who value convenience and are environmentally aware will find this lightweight mattress from Lullaby Earth to be an ideal solution.

Rating:

Ease of Use: 5/5
Environmental Impact: 4.5/5
Durability: 3.5/5

Best Budget-Friendly Choice - Graco Premium Foam Mattress - $149.99

Pros:

Accessible price point
Lightweight and easy to maneuver
Fits standard size cribs and toddler bed
6-year limited manufacturer’s warranty

Cons:

Basic design may lack some premium features

Highlights:

If you want the best mattress you can get for an affordable price, you need to check out the Graco Premium Foam Mattress. This crib mattress provides a snug and comfortable sleep experience at a relatively ower cost, catering to parents who are mindful of their budget.

Although it doesn't have the extravagant features found in more expensive models, the Graco Premium Foam Mattress still delivers straightforward utility and simplicity. It's designed to fit any standard crib, features a foam core for reliable support and comfort, and it's lightweight and easy to clean thanks to the high-quality, durable materials it's made from.

It's no surprise that this brand was given the Women’s Choice Award and the Parent Tested Parent Approved (PTPA) Seal from winning the 2023 Top Product Award. This shows that it's a mattress that offers dependable quality and value for families. It also comes with a 6-year warranty.

Rating:

Affordability: 5/5
Quality Assurance: 4.5/5
Feature Richness: 3/5

Best for Firm Support - Dream On Me Twinkle Mattress - $39.98

Pros:

Designed to meet the developmental needs of young babies
Highly recommended for its firmness

Cons:

Firmness level may not be ideal as toddlers grow

Highlights:

The Dream On Me Twinkle Mattress delivers essential strong support for babies, particularly newborn infants. How does it do this? Well, it's got a sturdy coil core that provides an optimal base for those crucial sleep periods.

This crib mattress has a perfectly calibrated firmness level which establishes it as one of the fundamental items in your baby nursery. However, one potential downside is that as time passes and your baby grows into a toddler, the firmness that was initially beneficial may no longer be as appealing to them.

Despite this, the Dream On Me Twinkle Mattress still stands out impressively among other crib mattresses, especially during those critical first months.

Rating:

Infant Support: 5/5
Longevity: 3.5/5
Comfort: 4/5

Best Hypoallergenic Option - Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress - $129.99

Pros:

Free from harmful chemicals
Enhanced durability compared to traditional foams
Hypoallergenic construction
Made with renewable resources

Cons:

May have less give than non-foam options

Highlights:

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress is designed to be a hypoallergenic haven, providing a safe and allergen-free sleeping environment for babies with sensitivities.

Crafted with soybean foam, this mattress not only enhances durability but also offers excellent hypoallergenic properties. Its core, made from environmentally-friendly, renewable materials, boasts superior durability compared to standard foams.

Parents who prioritize safety and support will appreciate the firmness of this mattress. However, some might prefer a slightly softer option as their child transitions from babyhood to an active toddler. For those focused on a pure, hypoallergenic sleep surface from day one, the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress ensures a refreshing, allergen-free environment.

Rating:

Hypoallergenic Properties: 5/5
Environmental Impact: 4.5/5
Softness & Comfort: 3.5/5

Best Dual-Sided Design - Babyletto Pure Core Mattress - $199.99

Pros:

Hypoallergenic with a waterproof cover
Dual-sided firmness for infants and toddler mattress
Recyclable polyester core
10-year warranty for the mattress, 1-year for the cover

Cons:

Thinner than some alternatives

Highlights:

Despite its thinner design, which might raise concerns about durability compared to other thicker options, the Babyletto Pure Core Mattress excels in both hypoallergenic benefits and ease of upkeep. It has a unique polyester core, which is pretty durable.

This crib mattress has an innovative design, helping the transition from newborn to toddler more comfortable. Newborn babies can be given the firmer side, while toddlers can get a cushier mattress topper. It also features a waterproof cover, making it simple to maintain and ensure a clean, healthy sleeping environment for your child.

The brand has so much faith in this product that they're providing a 10-year warranty on the mattress. Parents can rest easy knowing that this mattress is designed to withstand the test of time as their child grows.

Rating:

Versatility: 5/5
Health & Safety: 5/5
Durability: 4/5

Summary

As you've seen in this guide-slash-review, the range of crib mattresses available these days is as expansive and diverse as parents’ needs.

Brands today offer everything from supreme breathability to opulent coziness for your baby’s sleep haven. Of course, it’s important to select a mattress that reflects your personal priorities – whether that means committing to sustainable materials or staying within a certain budget – all while prioritizing the safety and health of your precious baby.

Luckily, you now possess the confidence required to sift through an ocean of mattresses dedicatedly crafted for cribs, ensuring delightful dreams for your infant and unwavering peace of mind for yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is breathability important in a crib mattress?

A breathable mattress is important because it reduces the chances of suffocation and prevents your baby from getting too hot. These crib mattresses allow for comfortable breathing even when your baby ends up on their belly while sleeping.

Can I use a regular twin mattress for my baby's crib?

We recommend that you select a baby-safe mattress for your baby's crib, as these are guaranteed to conform to legal regulations. Choosing an ordinary twin mattress isn't safe, as the baby could use it to climb over their crib and get out.

How do I know if a crib mattress is safe for my baby?

A crib mattress that's safe for your baby doesn't have harmful chemicals, has the right dimensions for the crib, and is ideally made of sustainable materials that can keep it breathable at night.

Are organic crib mattresses worth the extra cost?

Organic crib mattresses are worth the extra cost if you prioritize eco-friendliness and want to avoid harmful chemicals. These are guaranteed to be much safer than standard crib mattresses.

When should I replace my baby's crib mattress?

If the mattress in your baby’s crib begins to sag, tear, or does not fit tightly within the crib anymore, it is time to replace it due to wear and tear. For sanitary reasons, you should also think about getting a new mattress when a different baby will be using the crib.